Three years after their relationship made headlines and ended their time on GMA3, Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes are planning a wedding that’s striking a very different tone than their past.
According to Us Weekly, the engaged couple is extending invitations to their former spouses, Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig, a move that underscores just how much has shifted since the 2022 fallout that cost both Robach and Holmes their jobs at ABC.
The report notes that while invites are being sent, the couple is not expecting Shue and Fiebig to attend. Still, the gesture appears intentional.
A Hope for Peace, Not Pressure
An insider told the outlet that Robach “really wishes they could be a blended and normal family and all get along,” reflecting a desire for closure and calm rather than spectacle.
That theme reportedly carries into the ceremony itself. The wedding is expected to be a small, intimate gathering, around 50 to 60 guests, made up of close friends and family. Notably, the source said the event will not be “celebrity-heavy,” and, as of now, will not include anyone from GMA.
Children at the Center of the Day
While the exes may or may not attend, the couple’s children will play a meaningful role.
According to the insider, Robach hopes Holmes’ daughter Sabine, along with her own daughters Ava and Annalise, will serve as bridesmaids, a detail that signals how central family has become in this next chapter.
From Fallout to Forward Motion
Robach and Holmes’ relationship first became public in November 2022, triggering an immediate media storm. Both were suspended by ABC the following month and officially let go in January 2023.
At the time, both anchors were married, Robach to Shue, and Holmes to Fiebig, but the pair repeatedly insisted they did not cheat.
“We were outed as being in a relationship, but everyone else thought we were being outed as adulterers,” Holmes said on their Amy & T.J. podcast in December 2023. “We both at that point were in divorce proceedings.”
Robach echoed that explanation, adding that they each “had attorneys and mediators” and were already in the process of ending their marriages.
A Wedding Without Rushing — or Rewriting the Past
For much of 2024, Robach maintained that she and Holmes were in no rush to marry. Still, Holmes proposed in September 2025, and the couple confirmed their engagement publicly the following month after Robach had quietly worn her ring for weeks, unnoticed, she joked.
As for Shue and Fiebig, their lives have moved forward as well. The former spouses reportedly began dating in late 2023 and moved in together last year, forming a relationship that has unfolded far from the spotlight.
A Different Kind of Headline
This wedding won’t erase the past, and it doesn’t seem designed to. Instead, it reflects something quieter: boundaries, perspective, and an attempt to move forward without pretending history didn’t happen.
For Robach and Holmes, inviting their exes isn’t about optics or reconciliation. It’s about signaling where they are now, and how much distance they’ve put between themselves and the scandal that once defined them.
