Ahead of a new episode of American Idol, judge Luke Bryan shared a cheerful group photo featuring himself, Carrie Underwood, and Lionel Richie that got fans buzzing.
The image, posted to Bryan’s Instagram on April 7, 2025, showcased the trio smiling brightly, accompanied by a caption that celebrated the judging panel lineup.
Carrie Underwood also took to Instagram to highlight her appearance for the episode, posting two photos with the caption: “Tonight’s Look plus a bonus look…👀#AmericanIdol #CUonIDOL.” But while her post received plenty of likes and positive engagement, it also triggered a wave of fan speculation and debate—particularly around her appearance.
Among the top comments on social media was a viewer suggesting, “Someone looks like she has a baby bump…!?”
Another comment on Underwood’s post drew attention to a different detail, questioning, “Her knees do not match. Photoshop?” Meanwhile, one user on X (formerly Twitter) asked jokingly, “What’s up with her knees? 😆”
The reactions didn’t stop at speculation. Some fans even questioned whether Underwood looked like herself in the images.
It’s not the first time her appearances on American Idol have drawn scrutiny. Just days before, she shared another look from the show, this time wearing a striking black and silver blazer dress, paired with sparkling, rhinestone-covered silver boots.
The fashion-forward outfit received a mixed response online. While many applauded her daring and stylish choice, others zeroed in on her boots. One comment summed up the confusion: “Those boots look like leggings.”
Since joining the American Idol judging panel alongside Bryan and Richie, Underwood has consistently been in the spotlight—not just for her music insights but also for her bold style statements and evolving presence on the show.
